Addressing antisemitism in schools is a matter of safeguarding and responding to prejudice and discrimination.
Holocaust education is about teaching and learning a particular period in history, to deepen knowledge and understanding and develop insights into what it is to be human.
Learning about antisemitism in the 1930s and 1940s does not guarantee understanding of it in Britain in the 2020s.
That is not to say that we shouldn’t take this opportunity to consider the quality and provision of teaching about the Holocaust in England. Asking how we can make it better is valid.
We know that its provision is not uniform across schools. And as the review also highlighted, our research at the UCL Centre for Holocaust Education has repeatedly shown that significant misconceptions and gaps in historical knowledge about the Holocaust continue to persist.
Misunderstandings
These include troubling misunderstandings about who was responsible and why the Holocaust happened.
For instance, our latest student study found a third of students placed responsibility for the Holocaust with Hitler alone.
Elsewhere, fewer than half of those surveyed were able to identify Nazi-occupied Poland as the place where most of the killing took place.
Meanwhile, only 14 per cent were aware that around nine in ten Jewish children in Nazi-controlled Europe were murdered. These are deeply worrying realities.
They should prompt reflection on what is being done and how it could be improved. Particularly when the Holocaust has been a mandatory part of the national curriculum for history for 35 years. And especially given the increasing influence of the online world on our young people.
Follow the evidence
Our recent research showed, for instance, that three in five pupils said they had come across Holocaust content online that they had not gone looking for, most often on TikTok.
Any discussion about the future of Holocaust education in schools must heed this and other evidence from our research.
Because the answer to these knowledge gaps and pernicious misconceptions cannot simply be more of the same. We have to make tangible improvements to Holocaust education across schools in England.
Years of research and work in schools have allowed us to develop an evidence-informed toolkit for how to improve and further professionalise the quality of Holocaust education.
Part of that lies in developing a proper understanding of why the Holocaust should be taught, what the aims are, what content needs to be covered and how the subject can be approached.
Teachers have been calling for official guidance on this for years, but none has been delivered. As a result, neither schools nor students have a clear understanding of why the Holocaust is on the school curriculum.
Teachers need CPD
Another crucial lever we can pull to effect real-world change is professional development for teachers.
Our 2023 research with teachers shows the impact this can have on their subject knowledge and tackling misconceptions they may hold.
But not all professional development is effective. For example, we saw in 2023 that teachers who had undertaken high-engagement training, such as the Centre’s Beacon Schools programme, were much more able to correctly understand that the perpetrators did not kill because they had to.
Continuing professional development in Holocaust education therefore has the capacity to effect transformative generational change in schools, at scale.
We have seen this first-hand through the impact of our work with tens of thousands of teachers.
But to have this effect, Holocaust-related CPD has to be of the highest quality. It must be informed by evidence, it must be immersive and sustained and it must focus on improving pupil outcomes. It also needs to be anchored in the reality of the challenges teachers confront day in, day out.
Why we teach the Holocaust and what students need to learn remain unresolved. These questions will rightly be under scrutiny now that the Bell Review has been published.
But we also need to take this opportunity to confront uncomfortable truths, engage with the realities of classrooms around the country, and look to what the evidence suggests actually works.